Designing mixtures of varieties for multifunctional agriculture with the help of ecology. A review

Sébastien Barot, Vincent Allard, Amélie Cantarel, Jérôme Enjalbert, Arnaud Gauffreteau, Isabelle Goldringer, Jean Christophe Lata, Xavier Le Roux, Audrey Niboyet, Emanuelle Porcher

    Research output: Contribution to journalReview article

    34 Citations (Scopus)

    Abstract

    The study of natural ecosystems and experiments using mixtures of plant species demonstrates that both species and genetic diversity generally promote ecosystem functioning. Therefore, mixing crop varieties is a promising alternative practice to transform modern high-input agriculture that is associated with a drastic reduction of within-field crop genetic diversity and is widely recognized as unsustainable. Here, we review the effects of mixtures of varieties on ecosystem functioning, and their underlying ecological mechanisms, as studied in ecology and agronomy, and outline how this knowledge can help designing more efficient mixtures. We recommend the development of two complementary strategies to optimize variety mixtures by fostering the ecological mechanisms leading to a positive relationship between biodiversity and ecosystem functioning and its stability through time, i.e., sampling and complementarity effects. (1) In the “trait-blind” approach, the design of high-performance mixtures is based on estimations of the mixing abilities of varieties. While this approach is operational because it does not require detailed trait knowledge, it relies on heavy experimental designs to evaluate mixing ability. (2) The trait-based approach is particularly efficient to design mixtures of varieties to provide particular baskets of services but requires building databases of traits for crop varieties and documenting the relations between traits and services. The performance of mixtures requires eventually to be evaluated in real economic, social, and agronomic contexts. We conclude that the need of a multifunctional low-input agriculture strongly increases the attractiveness of mixtures but that new breeding approaches are required to create varieties with higher mixing abilities, to foster complementarity and selection effects through an increase in the variance of relevant traits and to explore new combinations of trait values.

    Original languageEnglish
    Article number13
    JournalAgronomy for Sustainable Development
    Volume37
    Issue number2
    DOIs
    Publication statusPublished - 1 Apr 2017

    Fingerprint

    Ecology
    Agriculture
    agriculture
    ecology
    Ecosystems
    Crops
    ecosystems
    low input agriculture
    Agronomy
    genetic variation
    agronomy
    Biodiversity
    cultivars
    field crops
    Design of experiments
    new combination
    socioeconomics
    experimental design
    biodiversity
    Sampling

    Keywords

    • Biodiversity
    • Complementarity effect
    • Crop breeding
    • Crop traits
    • Mixing ability
    • Mixtures of varieties
    • Multifunctional agriculture
    • Sampling effect

    ASJC Scopus subject areas

    • Environmental Engineering
    • Agronomy and Crop Science

    Cite this

    Barot, S., Allard, V., Cantarel, A., Enjalbert, J., Gauffreteau, A., Goldringer, I., ... Porcher, E. (2017). Designing mixtures of varieties for multifunctional agriculture with the help of ecology. A review. Agronomy for Sustainable Development, 37(2), [13]. https://doi.org/10.1007/s13593-017-0418-x

    Designing mixtures of varieties for multifunctional agriculture with the help of ecology. A review. / Barot, Sébastien; Allard, Vincent; Cantarel, Amélie; Enjalbert, Jérôme; Gauffreteau, Arnaud; Goldringer, Isabelle; Lata, Jean Christophe; Le Roux, Xavier; Niboyet, Audrey; Porcher, Emanuelle.

    In: Agronomy for Sustainable Development, Vol. 37, No. 2, 13, 01.04.2017.

    Research output: Contribution to journalReview article

    Barot, S, Allard, V, Cantarel, A, Enjalbert, J, Gauffreteau, A, Goldringer, I, Lata, JC, Le Roux, X, Niboyet, A & Porcher, E 2017, 'Designing mixtures of varieties for multifunctional agriculture with the help of ecology. A review', Agronomy for Sustainable Development, vol. 37, no. 2, 13. https://doi.org/10.1007/s13593-017-0418-x
    Barot, Sébastien ; Allard, Vincent ; Cantarel, Amélie ; Enjalbert, Jérôme ; Gauffreteau, Arnaud ; Goldringer, Isabelle ; Lata, Jean Christophe ; Le Roux, Xavier ; Niboyet, Audrey ; Porcher, Emanuelle. / Designing mixtures of varieties for multifunctional agriculture with the help of ecology. A review. In: Agronomy for Sustainable Development. 2017 ; Vol. 37, No. 2.
    @article{6f069ba8a34f4c0aa7dd797767cde4fa,
    title = "Designing mixtures of varieties for multifunctional agriculture with the help of ecology. A review",
    abstract = "The study of natural ecosystems and experiments using mixtures of plant species demonstrates that both species and genetic diversity generally promote ecosystem functioning. Therefore, mixing crop varieties is a promising alternative practice to transform modern high-input agriculture that is associated with a drastic reduction of within-field crop genetic diversity and is widely recognized as unsustainable. Here, we review the effects of mixtures of varieties on ecosystem functioning, and their underlying ecological mechanisms, as studied in ecology and agronomy, and outline how this knowledge can help designing more efficient mixtures. We recommend the development of two complementary strategies to optimize variety mixtures by fostering the ecological mechanisms leading to a positive relationship between biodiversity and ecosystem functioning and its stability through time, i.e., sampling and complementarity effects. (1) In the “trait-blind” approach, the design of high-performance mixtures is based on estimations of the mixing abilities of varieties. While this approach is operational because it does not require detailed trait knowledge, it relies on heavy experimental designs to evaluate mixing ability. (2) The trait-based approach is particularly efficient to design mixtures of varieties to provide particular baskets of services but requires building databases of traits for crop varieties and documenting the relations between traits and services. The performance of mixtures requires eventually to be evaluated in real economic, social, and agronomic contexts. We conclude that the need of a multifunctional low-input agriculture strongly increases the attractiveness of mixtures but that new breeding approaches are required to create varieties with higher mixing abilities, to foster complementarity and selection effects through an increase in the variance of relevant traits and to explore new combinations of trait values.",
    keywords = "Biodiversity, Complementarity effect, Crop breeding, Crop traits, Mixing ability, Mixtures of varieties, Multifunctional agriculture, Sampling effect",
    author = "S{\'e}bastien Barot and Vincent Allard and Am{\'e}lie Cantarel and J{\'e}r{\^o}me Enjalbert and Arnaud Gauffreteau and Isabelle Goldringer and Lata, {Jean Christophe} and {Le Roux}, Xavier and Audrey Niboyet and Emanuelle Porcher",
    year = "2017",
    month = "4",
    day = "1",
    doi = "10.1007/s13593-017-0418-x",
    language = "English",
    volume = "37",
    journal = "Agronomy for Sustainable Development",
    issn = "1774-0746",
    publisher = "Springer Science + Business Media",
    number = "2",

    }

    TY - JOUR

    T1 - Designing mixtures of varieties for multifunctional agriculture with the help of ecology. A review

    AU - Barot, Sébastien

    AU - Allard, Vincent

    AU - Cantarel, Amélie

    AU - Enjalbert, Jérôme

    AU - Gauffreteau, Arnaud

    AU - Goldringer, Isabelle

    AU - Lata, Jean Christophe

    AU - Le Roux, Xavier

    AU - Niboyet, Audrey

    AU - Porcher, Emanuelle

    PY - 2017/4/1

    Y1 - 2017/4/1

    N2 - The study of natural ecosystems and experiments using mixtures of plant species demonstrates that both species and genetic diversity generally promote ecosystem functioning. Therefore, mixing crop varieties is a promising alternative practice to transform modern high-input agriculture that is associated with a drastic reduction of within-field crop genetic diversity and is widely recognized as unsustainable. Here, we review the effects of mixtures of varieties on ecosystem functioning, and their underlying ecological mechanisms, as studied in ecology and agronomy, and outline how this knowledge can help designing more efficient mixtures. We recommend the development of two complementary strategies to optimize variety mixtures by fostering the ecological mechanisms leading to a positive relationship between biodiversity and ecosystem functioning and its stability through time, i.e., sampling and complementarity effects. (1) In the “trait-blind” approach, the design of high-performance mixtures is based on estimations of the mixing abilities of varieties. While this approach is operational because it does not require detailed trait knowledge, it relies on heavy experimental designs to evaluate mixing ability. (2) The trait-based approach is particularly efficient to design mixtures of varieties to provide particular baskets of services but requires building databases of traits for crop varieties and documenting the relations between traits and services. The performance of mixtures requires eventually to be evaluated in real economic, social, and agronomic contexts. We conclude that the need of a multifunctional low-input agriculture strongly increases the attractiveness of mixtures but that new breeding approaches are required to create varieties with higher mixing abilities, to foster complementarity and selection effects through an increase in the variance of relevant traits and to explore new combinations of trait values.

    AB - The study of natural ecosystems and experiments using mixtures of plant species demonstrates that both species and genetic diversity generally promote ecosystem functioning. Therefore, mixing crop varieties is a promising alternative practice to transform modern high-input agriculture that is associated with a drastic reduction of within-field crop genetic diversity and is widely recognized as unsustainable. Here, we review the effects of mixtures of varieties on ecosystem functioning, and their underlying ecological mechanisms, as studied in ecology and agronomy, and outline how this knowledge can help designing more efficient mixtures. We recommend the development of two complementary strategies to optimize variety mixtures by fostering the ecological mechanisms leading to a positive relationship between biodiversity and ecosystem functioning and its stability through time, i.e., sampling and complementarity effects. (1) In the “trait-blind” approach, the design of high-performance mixtures is based on estimations of the mixing abilities of varieties. While this approach is operational because it does not require detailed trait knowledge, it relies on heavy experimental designs to evaluate mixing ability. (2) The trait-based approach is particularly efficient to design mixtures of varieties to provide particular baskets of services but requires building databases of traits for crop varieties and documenting the relations between traits and services. The performance of mixtures requires eventually to be evaluated in real economic, social, and agronomic contexts. We conclude that the need of a multifunctional low-input agriculture strongly increases the attractiveness of mixtures but that new breeding approaches are required to create varieties with higher mixing abilities, to foster complementarity and selection effects through an increase in the variance of relevant traits and to explore new combinations of trait values.

    KW - Biodiversity

    KW - Complementarity effect

    KW - Crop breeding

    KW - Crop traits

    KW - Mixing ability

    KW - Mixtures of varieties

    KW - Multifunctional agriculture

    KW - Sampling effect

    UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85016975247&partnerID=8YFLogxK

    UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85016975247&partnerID=8YFLogxK

    U2 - 10.1007/s13593-017-0418-x

    DO - 10.1007/s13593-017-0418-x

    M3 - Review article

    VL - 37

    JO - Agronomy for Sustainable Development

    JF - Agronomy for Sustainable Development

    SN - 1774-0746

    IS - 2

    M1 - 13

    ER -