A Systematic Literature Review of Research-Derived Touchscreen Design Guidelines for Older Adults

Leysan Nurgalieva, Juan José Jara Laconich, Marcos Baez, Fabio Casati, Maurizio Marchese

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

1 Citation (Scopus)

Abstract

The distinct abilities of older adults to interact with touchscreen devices have motivated a wide range of contributions in the form of design guidelines, which aim at informing the design for the aging population. However, despite the growing effort by the research community, many challenges still remain in translating these research findings into actionable design guidelines, with reports hinting scant adoption or implementation issues, which ultimately hurt the development of more accessible interactive systems. In this systematic literature review, we look at the research-derived design guidelines that set the foundation for design guideline compilations and standards, analyzing the aforementioned issues from the perspective of experts trying to discover, classify, and evaluate the work on the area of touchscreen design guidelines for older adults. The review analyses 52 research articles resulting in 434 research-derived design guidelines for touchscreen applications. These guidelines are analyzed using a taxonomy that considered the older adults ability evolution and the design aspects that are the target of the recommendations. The results point to the use of different definition of older adults, which go as early as 55+, with the design of displays and interaction styles to accommodate to vision and dexterity declines as the most prominent areas of research. However, proposed guidelines and recommendations were validated in only 15% of articles analyzed. The analysis also revealed that identifying guidelines and characterizing their focus in terms of ability declines and design aspects addressed is a demanding activity and prone to error, given the quality of reporting and details offered in research articles.

Original languageEnglish
Article number8640032
Pages (from-to)22035-22058
Number of pages24
JournalIEEE Access
Volume7
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 1 Jan 2019

Fingerprint

Touch screens
Taxonomies
Aging of materials
Display devices

Keywords

  • accessibility
  • ageing
  • Information and communication technology
  • older adults
  • systematic literature review

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Computer Science(all)
  • Materials Science(all)
  • Engineering(all)

Cite this

A Systematic Literature Review of Research-Derived Touchscreen Design Guidelines for Older Adults. / Nurgalieva, Leysan; Jara Laconich, Juan José; Baez, Marcos; Casati, Fabio; Marchese, Maurizio.

In: IEEE Access, Vol. 7, 8640032, 01.01.2019, p. 22035-22058.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Nurgalieva, Leysan ; Jara Laconich, Juan José ; Baez, Marcos ; Casati, Fabio ; Marchese, Maurizio. / A Systematic Literature Review of Research-Derived Touchscreen Design Guidelines for Older Adults. In: IEEE Access. 2019 ; Vol. 7. pp. 22035-22058.
@article{03e954574cf5405fbc339e0a108a99b2,
title = "A Systematic Literature Review of Research-Derived Touchscreen Design Guidelines for Older Adults",
abstract = "The distinct abilities of older adults to interact with touchscreen devices have motivated a wide range of contributions in the form of design guidelines, which aim at informing the design for the aging population. However, despite the growing effort by the research community, many challenges still remain in translating these research findings into actionable design guidelines, with reports hinting scant adoption or implementation issues, which ultimately hurt the development of more accessible interactive systems. In this systematic literature review, we look at the research-derived design guidelines that set the foundation for design guideline compilations and standards, analyzing the aforementioned issues from the perspective of experts trying to discover, classify, and evaluate the work on the area of touchscreen design guidelines for older adults. The review analyses 52 research articles resulting in 434 research-derived design guidelines for touchscreen applications. These guidelines are analyzed using a taxonomy that considered the older adults ability evolution and the design aspects that are the target of the recommendations. The results point to the use of different definition of older adults, which go as early as 55+, with the design of displays and interaction styles to accommodate to vision and dexterity declines as the most prominent areas of research. However, proposed guidelines and recommendations were validated in only 15{\%} of articles analyzed. The analysis also revealed that identifying guidelines and characterizing their focus in terms of ability declines and design aspects addressed is a demanding activity and prone to error, given the quality of reporting and details offered in research articles.",
keywords = "accessibility, ageing, Information and communication technology, older adults, systematic literature review",
author = "Leysan Nurgalieva and {Jara Laconich}, {Juan Jos{\'e}} and Marcos Baez and Fabio Casati and Maurizio Marchese",
year = "2019",
month = "1",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1109/ACCESS.2019.2898467",
language = "English",
volume = "7",
pages = "22035--22058",
journal = "IEEE Access",
issn = "2169-3536",
publisher = "Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers Inc.",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - A Systematic Literature Review of Research-Derived Touchscreen Design Guidelines for Older Adults

AU - Nurgalieva, Leysan

AU - Jara Laconich, Juan José

AU - Baez, Marcos

AU - Casati, Fabio

AU - Marchese, Maurizio

PY - 2019/1/1

Y1 - 2019/1/1

N2 - The distinct abilities of older adults to interact with touchscreen devices have motivated a wide range of contributions in the form of design guidelines, which aim at informing the design for the aging population. However, despite the growing effort by the research community, many challenges still remain in translating these research findings into actionable design guidelines, with reports hinting scant adoption or implementation issues, which ultimately hurt the development of more accessible interactive systems. In this systematic literature review, we look at the research-derived design guidelines that set the foundation for design guideline compilations and standards, analyzing the aforementioned issues from the perspective of experts trying to discover, classify, and evaluate the work on the area of touchscreen design guidelines for older adults. The review analyses 52 research articles resulting in 434 research-derived design guidelines for touchscreen applications. These guidelines are analyzed using a taxonomy that considered the older adults ability evolution and the design aspects that are the target of the recommendations. The results point to the use of different definition of older adults, which go as early as 55+, with the design of displays and interaction styles to accommodate to vision and dexterity declines as the most prominent areas of research. However, proposed guidelines and recommendations were validated in only 15% of articles analyzed. The analysis also revealed that identifying guidelines and characterizing their focus in terms of ability declines and design aspects addressed is a demanding activity and prone to error, given the quality of reporting and details offered in research articles.

AB - The distinct abilities of older adults to interact with touchscreen devices have motivated a wide range of contributions in the form of design guidelines, which aim at informing the design for the aging population. However, despite the growing effort by the research community, many challenges still remain in translating these research findings into actionable design guidelines, with reports hinting scant adoption or implementation issues, which ultimately hurt the development of more accessible interactive systems. In this systematic literature review, we look at the research-derived design guidelines that set the foundation for design guideline compilations and standards, analyzing the aforementioned issues from the perspective of experts trying to discover, classify, and evaluate the work on the area of touchscreen design guidelines for older adults. The review analyses 52 research articles resulting in 434 research-derived design guidelines for touchscreen applications. These guidelines are analyzed using a taxonomy that considered the older adults ability evolution and the design aspects that are the target of the recommendations. The results point to the use of different definition of older adults, which go as early as 55+, with the design of displays and interaction styles to accommodate to vision and dexterity declines as the most prominent areas of research. However, proposed guidelines and recommendations were validated in only 15% of articles analyzed. The analysis also revealed that identifying guidelines and characterizing their focus in terms of ability declines and design aspects addressed is a demanding activity and prone to error, given the quality of reporting and details offered in research articles.

KW - accessibility

KW - ageing

KW - Information and communication technology

KW - older adults

KW - systematic literature review

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85062884003&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85062884003&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1109/ACCESS.2019.2898467

DO - 10.1109/ACCESS.2019.2898467

M3 - Article

VL - 7

SP - 22035

EP - 22058

JO - IEEE Access

JF - IEEE Access

SN - 2169-3536

M1 - 8640032

ER -